LAURA JAYES, HOST: Joining me live is Industry and Innovation Minister Tim Ayres. Tim, if I could just start on a macro issue because Jim Chalmers is addressing the ASIC conference this morning. He's talked about cutting spending, reducing red tape. It seems like there is, and correct me if I'm wrong, more of an urgency to do this now and in the next couple of months. Is that right?
SENATOR TIM AYRES, MINISTER FOR INDUSTRY AND INNOVATION AND MINISTER FOR SCIENCE: Well, at every budget and every fiscal update in the MYEFO, we have made savings because that's the right thing to do. And the Government is always focused on what the economic set of circumstances are around each budget or budget update –
HOST: But is this situation normal? Or is there a little bit more urgency, as I think we've all detected?
AYRES: Well, we're not in a normal situation. I mean, there is substantial inflationary pressure from the war in Iran, principally around petrol and diesel prices. They are flowing right through the economy. That is what is principally driving inflation. Absent that, we would have a completely different environment. And, of course, Jim’s comments today reflect –
HOST: But that happened months ago. So, I’m just wondering when the pivot started?
AYRES: So, the war began in February. Diesel prices in particular, which are the prices that really flow through, because everywhere, from agriculture and mining through to the transport and logistics that goes into supermarkets, has been affected. You know, decisions that farmers made in that February to June period, when planting seasons were on, are of course flowing through into supermarket prices now. So, there's substantial long tail. I mean, the war is still on. The war is still on, and we have a responsibility here to manage spending in the national interest. The Government is doing that. Everybody's got a responsibility across the Government to do that –
HOST: But you haven't just yet. And I’m just wondering why it's taken, it seems, six months for this urgency to come and for this pivot to actually be real? And to be honest, we haven't seen the cuts yet.
AYRES: The points where those decisions are made are the budget in May and in the lead-up to MYEFO, which is traditionally in December. So that work is progressing as you would kind of expect. There's nothing extraordinary about that. But the point I'm making is it's a response to –
HOST: But, Tim, you've said we're not in ordinary times. And there's nothing extraordinary about having, you know, a MYEFO and a budget. But which is? Shouldn't the Government, as a whole, have acted a lot earlier here and been more agile?
AYRES: The place where savings decisions are made and decisions about programs is in the budget and in budget updates.
HOST: And not outside of that?
AYRES: No, that's right. We're approaching this in an orderly way. Just the same as, remember what it was like in February and March when the war began and the Liberals and the Nationals and One Nation were running around telling people to hoard fuel. I had people come to me in NSW in the bush saying we have begun hoarding fuel because Angus Taylor is telling us that there's a fuel crisis. We didn't respond like that. In an orderly way, Anthony Albanese and Chris Bowen and Penny Wong set about utilising the relationships that we have established around the region, which were trashed by the previous government, and making sure that we have more fuel in Australia than we've had before. So, we're responding in an orderly way. We're dealing with the spending and savings decisions in an orderly way too –
HOST: But where's that orderly way got us? We've got five interest rate rises, a cost-of-living crisis, and that orderly way doesn't seem to have improved anyone's lives.
AYRES: Well, we are responsible for the decisions that we make in the fiscal environment and responsible for explaining those. The Reserve Bank is responsible for interest rate decisions. Neither of those two levers can possibly deal with the inflationary impact of a war in Iran, which has jacked up prices. So, we take responsibility for our part of that effort and we're doing that in a way which is focused on cost of living for ordinary people. But there’s a war in the Middle East.
HOST: So, you’re saying fiscal and monetary policy does not have an effect?
AYRES: It absolutely has an effect, and that's what I'm saying. We take responsibility for that.
HOST: What are you taking responsibility for?
AYRES: Well, making the right decisions, having regard to the economic environment, focusing on our responsibility around cost of living in particular. But I just say, at the same time, the driver of higher prices –
HOST: Yep, I get that –
AYRES: is a war in Iran –
HOST: war in Iran –
AYRES: That is the driver, and we don't step away from our responsibility. But let's be a bit real about what's going on.
HOST: Absolutely. Let's be a bit real about the impact government spending is having as well.
AYRES: Well, the problem for our opponents is that they make that argument, but they cannot point to –
HOST: No, but do you accept that government spending is, whatever component, small or large, is a component?
AYRES: Well, we all have a responsibility. The problem for our opponents is they have a giant black hole in their approach. Their claimed savings go nowhere near making up for the programs that they propose.
HOST: Sure, the election is more than a year away, you're in government.
AYRES: Yeah, but you've got a responsibility every day. It's not like we have responsibility and Angus Taylor has none.
HOST: Sure, you’ve got a responsibility. You've made savings and then spent them again.
AYRES: He has led an approach here where the only way of making up that black hole is cuts to Medicare, cuts to welfare, cuts to government programs. They're very reluctant to explain that.
HOST: Well, what are you going to cut, because you’ve promised cuts as well?
AYRES: Well, you'll have to wait, Laura, for when Jim fronts up with the Government's approach. We do these things in an orderly way. That's what people want from government.
HOST: Well, do they? Look at the polls. I mean, you’re not meeting any performance measure and it hasn't been this bad for 10 years since Labor was at civil war with itself. So, I'm not sure that orderly way is being endorsed by voters, if you know what I mean.
AYRES: Yeah, look, we're very focused on the fact that people are feeling the impact of those cost of living pressures. Very focused on that. That's why we have delivered cost-of-living relief. That's why we're focused on those fiscal fundamentals in the way that I've just described, and Jim will be setting some of that out over the course of the day, and Australians can be very confident that'll be seen in the MYEFO and the budget next year, but also a focus on delivering for reform for the future. Reform that makes a difference. Like what’s in the Parliament this week, Laura.
HOST: Yes, I was going to get to that. Let's talk about the gas reservation policy. There's two aspects to this that I really want you to focus on. Would you consider carving out WA as the Coalition wants to, as the WA Government wants to? The West Australian gas isn't an issue. We're focused on the East Coast. That is where I guess the problems are, if you want to couch it in that way. And, as a second part to my question, would you force these gas companies to sell at a price that is less than what it costs to extract?
AYRES: Well, can I start with the first proposition about Western Australia? We are inspired by the Western Australian Government and the approach that they took in 2005, and I'm old enough, Laura, to remember what happened then. The elements of the gas industry, not all of the gas industry, but elements of the gas industry were out there saying that the sky was going to fall in. The Liberals and Nationals in Perth said that this would be a disaster. It has been anything but. It has driven manufacturing investment in Western Australia and heavy industry. It has been the source of Western Australia's competitiveness. We want that for all of Australia and the legislation already delivers what it is that the Western Australian Government and some commentators are asking for. That is, two separate markets and Western Australia being able to operate with its reservation as it is, but it does it in a constitutionally proper way. We are engaged in discussions, as I've said publicly with the Liberals and Nationals and with the crossbench about this reform, everybody in the Australian Parliament should be voting for cheaper gas. This is a binary proposition, a fork in the road moment for Australia. We’ve either got cheaper gas or expensive gas.
HOST: So, you're not going to die on that hill, though? If you need to get a deal through, would you consider what the Coalition is proposing?
AYRES: Well, we've set out what our objectives are. We've set out what our objectives are.
HOST: Is it that or nothing?
AYRES: It's got to be constitutionally proper –
HOST: Yep. Is it that or nothing?
AYRES: But I can't go much further than that, LJ, on the show. We are engaged in discussions with our friends in the Liberals and Nationals on this question and with the crossbench and we're keeping those discussions, good faith discussions, confidential. But, I just make the point, we can either have a status quo position, where gas is too expensive for heavy industry and it goes offshore, I've watched firm after firm close, or we can take decisive action that puts Australian industry first and reserves Australian gas for Australian industry. That means low prices. Now, if the Liberals and Nationals want to vote for high prices, they should never put on a high-vis shirt ever again. They should never go to a manufacturing operation ever again because they won't be able to look people in the face and make the claims that they make about energy. This is a decisive moment for Australian industry. That's why we had all of the heavy industry firms, all of the key industrial employer organisations and the unions in here in Parliament this week speaking with one voice: vote for Australia.
HOST: It sounds like there is some flexibility in that and it sounds like some of this is being done in private. But, as a fundamental point here, should these gas companies be forced to sell at below the cost of production, and would they under your plan?
AYRES: Well, I don't think that's possible under the plan. You can't sell gas for below the cost of production. But it is true that the plan will mean there is a –
HOST: You can’t? So, there is a safety net in the legislation?
AYRES: Well, I just don't think that that's a possibility. But it is true that this eats into the profitability of very profitable gas firms, in the Australian interest. And it does put the interests of Australian consumers and Australian business and Australian heavy industry, it does tilt the scales back towards the local interest here, particularly for heavy industry.
HOST: And what does that do for future investment, do you think?
AYRES: Well, the pipeline of future investments is very strong and the industry, if you're on the side of do nothing, then you make this argument, right? And elements of, not all of, but elements of the gas industry have always made that argument. And look where it's got us. If you want to stay with the status quo, where that is the only interest that is being preferred, then there will be people who will make that argument because they'd rather we did nothing and Australian industry continued to decline. That's what is at stake here. What the reforms will deliver is a rebalancing of the scales so that we join the ranks of other major gas exporters. There's not a single other gas exporter in the world that doesn't have a gas reservation scheme. It's diminished Australia, it's reduced our industrial capability because we haven't had that reform. This is a complicated set of reforms because we're retrofitting onto an existing market, making commitments to respect existing contracts. So, it is complicated. It would have been simple if we'd done it in 2005 as a national reform rather than a state reform in Western Australia. But it delivers the right outcome. Low-cost gas as a source of future competitiveness for our heavy industry, for our big metal manufacturers, for our fertiliser, plastics, other manufacturers, the chemical industry. These are foundational industrial components of a complex future economy, and this reform is a fork in the road moment for Australia.
HOST: Sounds like some pretty spicy negotiations behind closed doors. Please keep us posted. Tim Ayres, always good to have you on the program. Appreciate your time.
AYRES: Thanks, Laura.
HOST: See you soon.
You were reading: Interview on News24 AM Agenda with Laura Jayes from Senator the Hon Tim Ayres.
Ministers for the Department of Industry, Science and Resources