Senator the Hon Tim Ayres

Minister for Industry and Innovation
Minister for Science

Press conference, Senate Courtyard, Parliament

Interviewer
Various
Subject
Press conference discusses the domestic gas reservation scheme.
E&OE

SENATOR TIM AYRES, MINISTER FOR INDUSTRY AND INNOVATION AND MINISTER FOR SCIENCE: This is a very important week for the Australians Senate and the Australian Parliament. It's a crossroads for industrial competitiveness and for gas prices here in Australia. Australia is the only major gas exporting economy that doesn't have a gas reservation plan. That means that in Australia, gas prices are too high for households, too high for business, and, particularly for the industry colleagues that I'm joined by today, gas prices have been too high for Australian heavy industry. I'm joined by Ben Eade, who is the boss of Manufacturing Australia, Matt Flugge from Chemistry Australia, and Gerry Tidd from Bluescope Australia, and they joined with other representatives of Australian heavy industry who, between them, employ hundreds of thousands of blue-collar Australians in our outer suburbs and in our big industrial regional economies. These are these are people who rely upon low-cost energy to protect the firms that they lead now and the hundreds of thousands of jobs they employ, but also it's fundamental to their considerations for future investment. The Albanese Government has a big pro-manufacturing agenda. We want to see more factories and reindustrialisation – we’re not building new factories in our CBDs or our kind of well-heeled harborside suburbs – but new factories being built, delivering good new jobs in our outer suburbs and our big industrial regional economies. This is a fork in the road. It's either cheap gas or expensive gas. It's either jobs onshore or more jobs and more closures flowing offshore. The Coalition, the Greens, the crossbench, really do have a choice: vote for Australia or vote for offshore manufacturing jobs. That's the choice for the Parliament. The whole Parliament should vote for this legislation over the course of this week. We're working hard, but I want to make sure that the voice of industry is heard here in this Parliament, so I invite Ben Eade from Manufacturing Australia to make some comments and then we’ll step it through and happy to take questions.

BEN EADE, CEO OF MANUFACTURING AUSTRALIA: Thank you, Minister. Look, our message is quite simple. If we want manufacturing in Australia, we need competitively priced, affordable gas. More than 900,000 people in Australia work in manufacturing jobs, more than 300,000 of those in gas-intensive industries. Gas is quite fundamental to manufacturing. It's an essential input into our plastics and chemicals industries that Matthew represents. It's the fuel that fires our kilns and furnaces, and, of course, it's the fuel that allows us to drive an increasingly renewable-based electricity grid at lowest cost. And so, if we want to have those benefits, if we want to have 900,000 manufacturing jobs and opportunities to grow those jobs, we need affordable gas. Gas reservation is not a new idea. It's been operating effectively in Western Australia since 2006. It's been recommended to every Federal Parliament since 2012, and every government in Canberra has made incremental steps towards the moment we find ourselves at now. Each of those incremental steps has helped, but none have successfully decoupled high Asian LNG prices from a domestic market where domestic costs of production and exploration set domestic prices for gas. So, this is really about making sure that all Australians, whether they're manufacturers or whether they're paying their household energy bills, receive the right return from the natural resources that we have in abundance in this country. So, we would urge the Parliament to pass these bills. It's in the national interest. Thank you.

MATTHEW FLUGGE, CEO OF CHEMISTRY AUSTRALIA: Our big challenge is we're a value-add industry. For every petajoule of gas that we use in chemical manufacturing, we create 30 times more economic value and 240 times more jobs than exploiting LNG. It's critical for our industry that we get long-term investment, long-term contracts, and the jobs that this creates is enormous. So, we also urge the Senate to pass this bill as soon as we can.

AYRES: So, we're happy to take questions, maybe direct it towards on this set of issues first, if that's okay.

JOURNALIST: The Coalition says that you can get a better balance of more gas, but also more investment in gas, if you reduce the extent of the oversupply. Is that something that you're open to?

AYRES: Well, maybe if I could take that question in two parts. Firstly, we're engaged in close discussions across the Parliament, including with the Liberals and Nationals, on the whole of the legislation, and I don't want to kind of go into the details of those discussions. They are free to canvas their views, of course, but my responsibility here is to manage those good faith discussions in a way that gets us to the outcome that these industry leaders need for Australia. The second point is, I've heard all of the arguments that are made about why we shouldn't do this, or why it should be slightly different or slightly weaker. I've heard all those arguments. We heard them in 2005 when the Western Australian Government legislated a gas reservation from Western Australia, and conservatives in Perth and elements of the industry said that the sky will fall in. Well, what have we seen? What have we seen in Western Australia since gas reservation was introduced in Western Australia? We've seen more manufacturing jobs, more manufacturing investment, and we've seen investment in the gas industry too. That is the approach we are seeking to deliver here. It’s been worked through carefully over an extended, painful period of negotiation and consultation to make sure that we've got the architecture right. That’s what we’re bringing to the Parliament.

JOURNALIST: So, you're not budging on a must sell obligation and a 10 per cent oversupply?

AYRES: Well, I’ve just indicated we're engaged in a careful discussion here. But the principle is, you're either for cheap gas or expensive gas. The Albanese Government's position is unambiguously for low-cost gas and certainty of supply for Australia, and that means more manufacturing jobs and lower costs for households.

JOURNALIST: Minister, as Mr Eade wrote about just recently and spoke to now, there's been a desire to correct, I suppose, the conversations around oversupply, that 10 per cent figure, the suggestion that really we're talking about a very modest, effective 4 per cent oversupply, a hit to the bottom line of about $130 million over 10 years to companies. Do you agree with Mr Eade that really this is about decoupling from high Asian prices from global price shocks, and less about you know these concerns around crashing a price or significantly reducing wholesale gas?

AYRES: This is freeing Australia from the global price, decoupling Australian gas prices, giving us more control here in Australia to make sure that we cannot just defend current jobs, which is really important, but that we can have a platform for investment where low-cost gas is a source of competitive advantage for Australia here. 

JOURNALIST: Are you wanting to pass the legislation by the end of the fortnight, and what would happen if you and the Coalition can’t agree?

AYRES: I make the point here that delay here is a disaster. I want to see this legislation through the Parliament over the coming days. That's the objective that we are working to secure. We'll work carefully across the Parliament, in a principled kind of way. This should really be above partisan politics here. There's a calculation, I think, for some people in the Parliament to put partisan interest first and try and wreck positive change for Australia. This is this is in the interests of every Australian business that consumes gas, particularly for our heavy industry, and it's in the interests of every household. Our gas prices have been too high. It's because previous parliaments and previous governments, as Ben indicated, have failed to grapple with this problem. The Albanese Government has a bold reform here. It’s what industry demands, we have worked it through carefully, and it’s time for the Parliament to vote for it.

JOURNALIST: WA Premier Roger Cook has put an open call out to all WA Labor Senators to lobby for a carve out, have you felt that pressure? Have you been contacted? Do you give also give Madeleine King credit for being at odds with the WA Labor Premier and also the WA gas sector?

AYRES: The scheme of the legislation makes this pretty clear that that objective has been achieved already. That is, there are two disconnected, physically disconnected, markets here, and Western Australia's approach is preserved in the legislation. We're inspired by the Western Australian approach. They said Western Australia-first on gas, and they were howled down at the time, but they were dead right. They were dead right. I want Australia's interests to be put here first, and the interests of Australian industry to be put first, and that’s what this legislation is all about.

JOURNALIST: Is this turning into a mess between State WA Labor and Federal Labor?

AYRES: No. I want to hear people's views. Roger Cook and the Western Australian Government are good partners here. We want to see more industrial investment in Western Australia. We want to make sure that gas is provided for Western Australian industry. We want to see more investment in minerals and resources and gas in Western Australia.

JOURNALIST: If you can't get a deal done with the Coalition, how seriously are you looking at working with the Greens to get this through, especially considering they’ve made it pretty clear they want a 25 per cent tax on all exports.

AYRES: Well, as I indicated, we're working across the Parliament. Working across the Parliament. We think the whole Parliament should vote for this. In the event that we don't get the whole Parliament, there's a limited range of pathways through, and we are actively working to secure, number one position, best position, the whole Parliament votes for it. Number two, of course, will settle for 50 per cent plus one. And, of course, they would be different packages. 

JOURNALIST: Just on the WA sticking point, you said that the legislation, as it stands, addresses the concerns and calls for a carve out. Can you explain actually what that looks like? Does it mean that if a state already has a reservation to a point they aren't captured by the law? What does that actually look like?

AYRES: Well, it means that the ministers can make orders consistent with the legislation to deliver that outcome consistent with the Constitution.

JOURNALIST: Are you confident you can see it done by Thursday? It does feel like we've seen a lot of your face, and we’re grateful for your attendance, but sometimes it's a sign of worry. So, is it something you think can be done by Thursday?

AYRES: I do think it can be done by Thursday. The legislation is complex because we're trying to retrofit onto a market that doesn't work something that should have been done between 2001 and 2005, so it's necessarily more complex in order to achieve that objective. But it's been so well ventilated that the issues in front of us are actually quite straightforward. And in the end, this is a binary position, and I guess that's why I've been up and about this week because I want Australians to understand how important this legislation is and what the choice is in front of them. If you're the kind of character who puts on the high-vis shirt right and fronts up in manufacturing workplaces and wants to tell people that you're on their side, you need to vote for this legislation. You cannot look working Australians, blue-collar workers in the eye, if you've voted against gas reservation. Every closure that people see, every investment decision that's not made that people won't see, is on your head if you don't vote for this legislation that is so plainly in the national interest. You know, people like to stick the high-vis on, sometimes inside conference halls. I understand that. Don't do it if you're not voting for the legislation.

JOURNALIST: AI. There's a major campaign, Minister, of creative groups that’s launching I think today or tomorrow saying they’ve got concerns with what’s happening with copyright. I know that’s not exactly in your portfolio, but you are sort of the Minister for AI, essentially. APRA, ARIA, Writers’ Guild, Screen Producers’, all these thirty-something groups and media organisations and so forth. They're hearing the promises and so forth that the Prime Minister and Minister Rowland have made about no changes to water-down copyright. What would you say to groups that are still concerned about what the Government’s plans might be in the copyright space and how it might affect rightsholders and publishers?

AYRES: Nothing has changed in terms of the Government's approach. I understand the anxiety, though. For those workers, the status quo is no good for them. Their work is currently being appropriated, today, offshore. We have set out a program for a scheme of legislation that would protect those rights, make sure that artificial intelligence investment in Australia is on Australia's terms, whether that's in terms of productivity or the electricity and water and other considerations, but we don't want, in Australia, a position like we've seen emerge overseas. It's an important technology for our future competitiveness, for our future resilience, and our future security and productivity. We want to make sure it's adopted here in Australia’s terms. 

JOURNALIST: So, status quo is no good. Does mean there would have to be some copyright changes, and when will we start seeing this package?

AYRES: Well, the package will be released by the government in due course. I can't help you with the timetable for that. We’ve been very clear. We’re not about undermining copyright here. That commitment has been made so many times now, and those groups that you have spoken about, this is not the first time they've been engaging with the Government. We've been engaging very closely with all of them, led by the Attorney-General, right over the course of this very long discussion. And it's an important discussion for Australia. Thanks very much, everybody. See you shortly. Thank you.

You were reading: Press conference, Senate Courtyard, Parliament from Senator the Hon Tim Ayres.