OLIVER PETERSON: And joining us live is the Federal Minister for Resources, the Labor MP for Brand, Madeleine King. Good afternoon.
MINISTER MADELEINE KING: Hi, Ollie, how are you?
OLIVER PETERSON: I'm good, thank you, Minister. And the Shadow Assistant Treasurer to the Shadow Treasurer, the WA Liberal Senator, Dean Smith. G'day.
DEAN SMITH: G'day to you, Ollie, and to Madeleine. I'm calling, of course, from Canberra, where the Senate is sitting by itself this week.
OLIVER PETERSON: Having fun.
MINISTER MADELEINE KING: Doing all the hard work, Dean.
DEAN SMITH: Doing the hard work, indeed. Madeleine. That's right.
OLIVER PETERSON: Absolutely. I know this is off topic, but you just heard that breaking news from Cameron Bancroft regarding sandpaper gates. Minister King, you first. Do you think a forum's going to put this all to bed once and for all? Is this what we need? Can Australian cricket move on?
MINISTER MADELEINE KING: Gee, Ollie, you know I don't like cricket. I love cricket.
OLIVER PETERSON: I know you do.
MINISTER MADELEINE KING: So, this is. It's really difficult, isn't it? And it's happened a long time ago, but we all remember it because it was. It was such a display of what we would just think of as, well, not cricket, bad sportsmanship, cheating. So, you know, it sounds like a lot of people have got to get a lot off their chest, and if this is how it's going to be, this is how it's going to be, I suppose.
OLIVER PETERSON: Senator Smith.
DEAN SMITH: Well, Ollie, I don't mind being honest with you and your listeners. I'm probably the last West Australian to ask about cricket. But, but let me just -- the little bit that I do know about this. I think that reputations, if they've been damaged, need to be restored. Australians do want to have confidence, high-level confidence in their sporting stars and sporting codes. It sounds like this does need to get cleared up pretty quickly. So, I'm one for transparency, some truth, and once all of that is achieved, let's move on. So, particularly younger Australians can have high levels of confidence in their sporting stars.
OLIVER PETERSON: It's interesting though, isn't it, that we clearly have a rift within the playing group and have had for some time, yet their performances on the field would probably indicate otherwise. You both work in a profession, by being politicians, where you probably keep your, you know, your friends close but your enemies closer, or even if they're on the opposite sides or within your own parties. Dean Smith.
DEAN SMITH: Well, I think in these sorts of things, you know, how you do things is just as important as what you do. So, how you choose to bring a grievance to the attention of your colleagues or the leadership of your party is very, very important. You know, the Liberal Party has very, very different, you know, arrangements and conventions compared to the Labor Party. So, I think how you do it, you know, sharing with colleagues early so there is, you know, no surprises for leadership and for your parliamentary colleagues is very, very important. Being clear about your reasoning around issues is very important. And if you're always speaking from a position of, you know, authenticity, honesty, genuine grievance or concern or particular, you know, conscience, position, then I think colleagues know that. So. But you know, team does matter in politics as much as it matters in sport. Yes.
OLIVER PETERSON: It is interesting though, isn't it? Madeleine King. We've had this ide idea of the rivalries this afternoon. As we know now, the Bears are going to be kicking off their season against the Sea Eagles. Great rivalry of rugby league being reignited. But there are some parallels with what we're talking about here, right for the moment, what you've just heard out of Cameron Bancroft and what you have in politics. And I know you're again a mad keen sports fan with the Fremantle Dockers. Have you got a greatest rivalry of all time yourself?
MINISTER MADELEINE KING: Oh, look, I heard you show a bit earlier, Ollie. I mean, I don't think we can go past the rivalry between the Aussies and the Poms. And I say Poms quite affectionately. My dad, I was once one when I used to have British citizenship, we used to call it a ‘Pommy passport’, you know. So, I just think the Ashes rivalry has got to be the one I really enjoy watching and being a part of, and the fact that it's not every year and that it's in a different place, you know, an alternate, test matches and test series. So, I think that's my kind of favourite.
OLIVER PETERSON: Alright. What about you, Dean? What's your sort of favourite role? Is it Liberal versus Labor?
DEAN SMITH: Well, Ollie, given this is a political show on the ABC, I was hoping that Madeleine might have been able to sort of reveal some of those sort of political rivalries inside the government at the moment.
MINISTER MADELEINE KING: We don't have any, Dean, you know that.
OLIVER PETERSON: You're all on the same page, aren't you? You're all friends, aren't you, Madeleine? Everybody gets on with each other.
DEAN SMITH: Well, I should, Ollie. I should actually thank Madeline for her Christmas card.
OLIVER PETERSON: Well, that's very kind.
MINISTER MADELEINE KING: It's good, isn't it, Dean?
DEAN SMITH: It was, actually. You did commit to coming into the studio with me. I was getting -- starting to take this a bit personally.
MINISTER MADELEINE KING: No, no, I know. I knew you were in the Senate this week and I'm down in Rockingham, so I'll make sure I do before Christmas.
OLIVER PETERSON: Fair enough.
MINISTER MADELEINE KING: I'll drop one off to Ollie as well.
OLIVER PETERSON: All right, it's 16 to four. It's behind party lines if you want to get involved this afternoon. 1300 22 1025. WA looks set to have secured a carve-out in the federal gas reservation policy. The last-minute change, it hasn't been voted, but it is all but agreed. Madeleine King, have you capitulated to the WA Premier here?
MINISTER MADELEINE KING: The WA Premier, Roger Cook, is the Member for Kwinana, one of my constituents and a firm friend of mine, and has been for many years. So, I do want to be clear from the very start, from the very start of when we have been formulating this policy around the gas reservation, which has come off the back of the gas market review. And all in all, we've been 18 months working through all of the issues around this, and there are many, because it is very complex, the gas market in this country.
But one thing from the very start, among a couple of others, was that everyone acknowledged WA has a reservation system. It is working, and we would like to replicate it in a workable form for the rest of the country. So, there was always provision for that to be acknowledged so that WA wouldn't be affected adversely in the scheme.
How we finalise that and how we make sure Western Australia is happy with that, which they now are. I think it was inevitable that that would go until these sort of final negotiating moments, as everyone became more clear about the various amendments that will be proposed.
Because we are being very open and consultative about how we seek to finalise this scheme, because it does have a lot of stakeholders, there is a lot at stake; it's a really important national economic reform. And so, you know, we're pleased we're able to have a mechanism whereby, after the decisions are made around the west coast market and its adequate supply, which it is very adequately supplied, and everybody knows that it can have that kind of consideration that lasts permanently.
OLIVER PETERSON: Senator Smith, go ahead.
DEAN SMITH: Well, Ollie, I don't want to steal your job, but perhaps I could ask Madeleine a question. What is the form in which that carve-out will be achieved? Because I'm looking at a media report here from the West Australian newspaper that says that a carve-out is not actually ironclad.
MINISTER MADELEINE KING: Well, this is a mechanism – the gas market nationally is separated through the legislation into two markets. One is the East Coast, and one is the West Coast. And in each of those markets they will, we will, the government of the day.
We are able to set a domestic supply obligation, and that domestic supply obligation we based on whether there is adequately supplied market, and in Western Australia we have seen over the past years that, indeed, under the WA Labor's policy of a gas reservation scheme, that it is adequately supplied.
And when that determination is made, what we have done, and changed recently, is remove the sunsetting clause. Which is an automatic provision under Federal laws. There's a lot of detail around that, but I won't go into that, has been removed such that any determination is permanent.
DEAN SMITH. So, Ollie, the Coalition's position so, we have supported a gas reservation policy and did so under the leadership of Peter Dutton. Shortly coming onto the program, I had an opportunity to speak to Senator Susan McDonald from Queensland, who is the Coalition's Resources and Northern Australia Shadow Minister.
We're not yet in a position to support the bill, but we have been working and always gave a commitment that we would work constructively with the Government on this matter. The Coalition's position has really sort of hinged around four key elements or four key concerns. The most important one, of course, for West Australians is the West Australian carve-out, and we'll wait to see what that actually looks like in the detail. Secondary issue was the issue of the must sell provisions in the legislation and the 110 per cent oversupply provisions. So, these have been sort of concerns. We've been sharing them with the government. Senator McDonald was on Radio National this morning talking about it. But a key element of our concern has also been the broad use of Ministerial discretion in the legislation. Our argument is more generally, but specifically here, that where broad Ministerial discretion exists, they undermine investment confidence. And of course that is very, very important because we're interested in the issue of price and affordability for gas today, but also to ensure that there's that continuing investment in gas into the future. It doesn't look like the legislation will be dealt with this week unless the Government in the Senate seeks to try and change the program for tomorrow. More likely the matter will be dealt with next week. But the Coalition is engaging constructively. We are interested in gas reservation policy as first principles.
And if I could just say from a West Australian perspective, I think once this matter is resolved, I think it's really, really important for West Australians to then focus on the operation of the West Australian Gas Reservation Scheme, because we have had a state parliamentary report into this matter. There are risks of rising gas prices in Western Australia in the short term that will put manufacturing jobs in Western Australian industry at risk. So, once this matter is resolved at the federal level, then I think it would be really, really helpful for Western Australian parliamentarians, federal and state, to sort of put their mind to some of those issues that are emerging in the WA gas reservation scheme.
OLIVER PETERSON: Senator Smith, how quickly do you want your party, though, to come to some sort of position? Because this is being wedged, whether everybody likes it or not, as the West versus the rest.
DEAN SMITH: It's in no one's issues that bad decisions get made hastily. There's another week of the Senate. The government knows that; the Coalition knows that. Yes, the government will have a variety of priorities next week in which it wants to legislate, but getting issues around energy policy particularly but gas reservation policies correct, is important, is paramount. And making sure that that West Australian carve-out is, is crystal clear and guaranteed and everyone is confident that that is what has been achieved and that is what the government is offering, and that is the form in which the amendment will come to the Senate next week. I think that is important. We're engaging constructively. These are important issues. But West Australians should understand that, you know, we want to be totally satisfied and 100 per cent confident that the West Australian scheme is protected.
OLIVER PETERSON: All right, Madeleine King, Dean Smith with us for Behind Party Lines at 8 to 4. If you'd like to put a question to our federal colleagues. 1300 22 1025. Ziggy says: Hey, Minister King, how come all week Labor have been saying that it goes against our constitution to have a carve-out for WA?
MINISTER MADELEINE KING: Oh, well, I mean, it would do if you excluded Western Australia from the whole scheme. So, this is not doing that. What we are proposing in the amendment, the amendment that Premier Roger Cook is supporting, because we've worked with him on it, is that WA is one of the markets within the scheme, the Western Market, and a decision can be made by the Minister of the Day to exempt it if supply is adequate. Which we know and we have seen that it is.
So, what would be unconstitutional, or have the risk of not satisfying the Constitution, is if we just said WA is not a consideration one little bit. And we simply can't do that. And then, you know, that's our Federation, and I know, you know, not all West Australians love it, but it is really important to us.
And of course, there are so many benefits Western Australia gets from the Commonwealth Government. AUKUS is one. And that's been a massive boon for industry, the defence industry and other associated industries in Western Australia.
So, you know, we're working really very hard and have worked very hard over 18 months. But then, as it comes to the pointy end, when legislation is in Parliament more recently, to get this agreement to make sure that WA's gas reservation scheme is respected. And it will be.
DEAN SMITH: And this is the key point, and Madeleine has revealed it in response to her answer to your listener, and it is the issue of the broad discretionary power. It will be interesting to see how that power has been reduced. So, this is, so this is the key issue. Is the Ministerial discretionary power the right mechanism to guarantee the carve-out?
Is that Ministerial discretion suitably narrow enough? And you know, so Madeleine in her answer has revealed that the real know the real tension in this particular matter.
OLIVER PETERSON: 1300 22 1025 behind party lines with Dean Smith and Madeleine King. Senator Smith, were you surprised to see the government and Tony Burke back down on the proposed changes to backpacker visas? Obviously there still will be some changes, but not as harsh as they were as originally announced.
DEAN SMITH: Well, pleased is probably the emotion that I had, and I'm sure many, many other people across regional communities were happy with the government's back down, and congratulations to all of those across the community that were, you know, involved in making the case to the government and to other people that those backpacker changes would have been very, very detrimental to regional communities.
But the matter's not over, Ollie. You know, the Coalition wants to see the cap axed. We want the ballot gone, and we want the government to be giving much greater levels of confidence to small business and regional communities that need backpackers to support their local communities and their local businesses. That is especially important as we go into the Christmas season.
Very, very important for tourism businesses, fruit picking seasons beginning. I've heard stories about lack of workers for cherries and others. So, motels, hotels, roadhouses, those of us that travel regularly across regional communities in Western Australia, indeed across the whole country, know that backpackers are critical to supporting local businesses in regional communities. And we want to make sure that at this time of the year, but more generally, that businesses are given every level of support that they need.
OLIVER PETERSON: On that ballot, Minister King, something that the AHA WA CEO Bradley Wood said yesterday, as Senator Smith just said, there is there still any wiggle room that this may be abolished altogether?
MINISTER MADELEINE KING: Oh, look, I mean that's decision-making that has to, you know, I won't tread on too much on the toes of my Ministerial colleagues, but importantly the government has listened to the concerns, and indeed we were always up for, you know, working out those issues and making sure we could find a pathway that works.
And I know, and I accept that not everyone is going to be, 100 per cent happy, but we do have to make sure we moderate our migration so that is sustainable. And I know working holiday makers, they come, and they go; some of them come, and they stay, and they stay too long. So, we've got to manage that, and any responsible government would.
But in relation to the ballot, we are introducing the transitional arrangements. So, that registration invitation process was going to start this month. We've now put it back into March of next year, so there's a bit more time to work with the Minister for Home Affairs and his team around, around that and other settings.
But really importantly, we do want to stick to an orderly migration process.
OLIVER PETERSON: John makes a comment that it's not a great look that Roger Cook has flown to Japan, Minister King, to sell the gas that hasn't been approved on the same day that he claims a gas carve-out for fossil fuel companies and not the WA people.
MINISTER MADELEINE KING: What I would actually say in response to that is congratulations to Inpex, a Japanese gas corporation that celebrated its 40th year of activities in Australia just last night. And I was pleased to be able to deliver a speech there.
They have invested over $80 billion into our economy and that of the Northern Territory, and many, many, many thousands of jobs, and taxation and revenue into this state and into our friends in the Northern Territory. And it's the largest investment of any Japanese company in any country in the world other than Japan. So, it's a really important project, and they're very important partners to our country.
OLIVER PETERSON: Senator Smith?
DEAN SMITH: Well, I think Japanese investment is very, very important, not just in gas, but more generally, particularly important for Australia, but especially important for a state like Western Australia. Energy is just not a domestic issue anymore. It goes to the heart of geopolitical tensions. And I think it's very, very important that Australia play its role in being a very reliable energy supplier to places like Japan and South Korea. These issues are critical for regional safety and stability now, and you know, I welcome Inpex's participation in the Australian economy. Absolutely.
And the--and you know, Western Australia's relationship with Japan has been remarkable when you think of the strength of the iron ore industry, the gas industry. And I think, you know, the Western Australian forefathers, I think, have done a remarkable job at solidifying that relationship. The prosperity of every West Australian is dependent on relationships like this that we have with Japan and our Asian neighbours.
OLIVER PETERSON: Senator Smith, Minister King, thank you very, very much for your time. Appreciate it.
MINISTER MADELEINE KING: Thanks a lot, Ollie.
DEAN SMITH: Thank you.
OLIVER PETERSON: That is Madeleine King, the Federal Minister for Resources, and Dean Smith WA Liberal Senator, the Shadow Assistant Treasurer to the Shadow Treasurer.
You were reading: Interview on ABC Perth with Oliver Peterson from The Hon Madeleine King MP.
Ministers for the Department of Industry, Science and Resources