SENATOR TIM AYRES, MINISTER FOR INDUSTRY AND INNOVATION AND MINISTER FOR SCIENCE: Well, this is an important week for Australia's Parliament. I can tell you that as an active participant, as a trade union official in my life prior to coming into this Parliament, I watched manufacturing firm after manufacturing firm close down and go offshore because Australia's gas prices have been too high. It's been a wrecking ball through Australian industrial workplaces, gas prices that have been set by international markets, not by Australia's national interest. The Parliament will have a choice over this week about whether the Australian Parliament acts in the Australian national interest and delivers structural economic reform that puts downward pressure on Australian gas prices and reserves Australian gas for Australians, that's the choice that's in front of this Parliament.
You'll have seen overnight a coalition of Australian industry, trade unions, heavy industrial firms, the chemical industry, the metal industry, the Australian Industry Group, Manufacturing Australia, responsible for employing hundreds of thousands of blue-collar Australians in our outer suburbs and our industrial regions. They don't normally come together, but they have come together to reinforce that it is in the national interest and in the interests of blue-collar Australia for this important reform to pass through the Senate. So we can deliver certainty, lower costs, protect current industry, deliver for future industrial investment, and make Australia stronger with this important reform.
The same coalition of vested interests who exist outside this Parliament that have frustrated reform are, of course, present now, and they are entitled to make all of those arguments. It is true that this places a heavy burden on our gas producers in the Australian national interest to deliver up to 20 per cent of Australian gas for Australian industry. It is the right thing to do. Same arguments were made in relation to Western Australia's gas reservation. When the whole of Australia acted, the Western Australian Government put Western Australia's interests first in the early 2000s. Well, the Albanese Government here is acting in the same way to put Australia's interests first.
THE HON MADELEINE KING, MINISTER FOR RESOURCES AND MINISTER FOR NORTHERN AUSTRALIA: Thanks, Tim. This week the Senate of this Parliament will consider and debate this vital national and landmark economic reform in the form of the national gas reservation scheme. This is all about making sure Australian households, Australian consumers, Australian businesses, Australian industry are able to access Australian gas at affordable prices. We have had, over decades and successive governments of all kinds, ad hoc response to issues in the gas market, to shortages of supply, to runaway skyrocketing prices, which are often brought about by international conflict and global headwinds. And this economic reform is about ending all of that to bring in an enduring, long-term market reform that introduces stability to the gas market. It is in the national interest, as Minister Ayres has said, that this progress through the Senate this week, so we can move on with the legislation, have it implemented so over the course of next year, we can set about having a national gas reservation scheme in place by the start of 2028. That will enable the exporters themselves to have in place systems so that they can reserve up to 20 per cent of their gas for Australian people. That's an important principle.
This is an industry that has supplied and done a good job and I would want to recognise the contribution of the 3 gas exporters, particular in on Curtis Island, in Queensland, in Gladstone, as to how they have supplied the domestic market. They, along with me, would agree that the Australian Domestic Gas Security Mechanism and the Heads of Agreement could be improved. Has indeed probably passed its use-by date, and they will be replaced by the national gas reservation scheme to make it more predictable, to make it more stable, and so we can all get on with the job of making sure Australians have access, as I said many times before, to affordable gas and make sure that that supply is secure. This set of legislation, this package, has been consulted on extensively, and in fact, I can barely think of any policy of this government, or indeed of any government, that has had more consultation over a longer period.
We started the Gas Market Review some time ago. Announced the scheme following that review last December. It's about 18 months. We've been going through a really extensive, a really productive, a really open consultation process that has taken in everybody, everyone that has any concern around gas supply in this country has contributed to the design of the scheme. We will not agree on everything, but we have, I believe, found a sensible pathway through to make sure that there is enduring market reform to ensure that Australians have access to Australian gas at affordable prices.
So, I urge all senators to support the legislation. It will be a matter for them. A vote for this legislation is a vote in support of making sure Australians have access to Australian gas. A vote against it just maintains the status quo, and the status quo is not really in the national interest. So, once again, I urge all senators this week to consider the legislation, debate it as you will, and support it. I guess we go to questions now.
JOURNALIST: Minister, as you said, this would place a heavy burden on gas producers. You also said you know you've been watching manufacturers crying out, going out of business. The smaller domestic gas producers have said over and over again, this is basically going to put them out of business. After shaved low prices, it's going to stifle investment. Are you effectively saying you'd rather see smaller domestic gas producers go out of business if that meant keeping manufacturing viable in the long run in Australia?
AYRES: Well, this is a very simple choice. It's a very simple choice for the Australian Parliament. One road buys lower gas prices and more manufacturing jobs, the source of future Australian strength and future Australian competitiveness. On the other road – the do nothing road – is the status quo with uncertainty and incapacity to reach long-term contracts, more expensive gas, and less jobs. That is that is the choice in front of the Australian Parliament.
All of these arguments are very familiar because they are the same arguments that were made in the early 2000s in Western Australia and elements of industry said that the sky would fall in. Well, what we've seen, because the Western Australian Government acted then, is more manufacturing in Western Australia, lower gas prices as a source of Western Australia's competitive advantage. But on the East Coast, less jobs, closures, a weakening industrial economy. The Western Australian Government acted in Western Australia's interest then. Previous Australian governments should have acted in the Australian interest then. This is a tough reform, but the Albanese Government is acting now to secure lower gas prices and competitiveness for Australian industry.
JOURNALIST: But is there a choice between domestic gas production and domestic manufacturing? Is there a trade-off?
AYRES: Well, it's certainly true that the gas reservation eats into very high profits in the gas sector, but it does it in the national interest in a way that protects hundreds of thousands of blue-collar jobs in our outer suburbs and our industrial regions.
JOURNALIST: The West Australians up front on the WA issue. It does seem to be a sticking point, but also the points you make about you know the constitutional limitations. What room and movement is there on that matter?
KING: The legislation as it stands is very clear. We set up two markets, and that just reflects reality that on the western side of the country they have an interconnected system of pipelines that does not connect to the East Coast for the geographical challenges of having pipelines go across the Great Sandy Desert and the Nullarbor. And then there's the East Coast market, which has its own set of interconnected pipelines. That makes sense. So, the Western market, it is available to the decision makers and we have to respect that this legislation has not yet passed, so pre-empting decisions is a difficult thing to do to be avoided, but it does set up the opportunity for the Domestic Supply Obligations within the Western market to be set at zero, or very low, depending on whether that market is well supplied. All evidence to this stage demonstrates, and Western Australia will tell you that the market is indeed well supplied. So, that is the opportunity, and the constitution is important. As legislators, we have to respect it. State governments have to respect it, and hopefully they will.
JOURNALIST: So when the Coalition is pointing out that this is a sticking point for them, or is it just a major point of concern? Do you think that's just bluster from them?
KING: I've had really good discussions with the Coalition. I wouldn't want to speak for them, but I think the general consensus is that the status quo can't remain. This ad hoc response to crises in gas supply is no way to run a national gas market or even an eastern states market. So, something has to change. The thing is, Western Australia's domestic reservation is accounted for, and it's an inspiration for the whole thing. I mean, Minister Ayres has just gone through support for that. But we have to make this scheme robust in the national sense, and I'm confident we will do that. It'll be up to the, and we keep speaking to the Coalition and others if they have any queries about how we see that western market accounted for in this program.
JOURNALIST: Minister, what's the difference between your policy and what the Coalition took to the last election?
KING: My understanding from the last election is that the Coalition took a form of export tax, and I'm sorry there wasn't much detail around their position, so I can't comment more fully. I'm not aware of any revised position if there is one.
JOURNALIST: They look pretty similar to what they had a year ago. Does that put further pressure on them to support this, or does that –
KING: Well, I think the question is clear, and the decision is clear. Does the Coalition want to support assured gas supply for Australians and affordable pricing? I mean, it's pretty simple proposition here. And for the industry itself, we're not asking that much of them. It's about making sure they save a small proportion of what they export. And when they export [inaudible] on pricing, existing contracts, which we've very been very clear of our respect for those foundational contracts with our really important international partners, but to make sure Australians continue to support this industry, which has provided extraordinary advantages to this country in terms of its geostrategic relevance in the region, in terms of its contribution to GDP, in terms of the jobs in Far North Queensland, in the southern states as well, and of course across Western Australia. Indeed, extraordinary number of jobs in the Northern Territory. They just need to hold a little bit of it back for Australians.
JOURNALIST: You've both referenced how WA has inspired this, but the WA Government opposes the bill in its current form. Does that kind of destabilise? I guess that argument that you know WA has done this, but they're actually the ones who are opposing it. And on that, would you give them what they're asking for in terms of a carve out that isn't up to ministerial discretion?
KING: Well, if we were to have a national gas reservation scheme, Western Australia falls part of it, just to meet the requirements of constitutional validity. I think the Western Australian Government knows how important it would be for the stability on the East Coast, and also if we can get this legislation passed, so that we do introduce an enduring framework, so that we don't have to keep coming back to this all the time. And the sooner we move off talking about gas, probably the better for everyone, so that we can make sure that market becomes well supplied on the East Coast as well as the West Coast. I know the West Australian Government knows our position. There is an opportunity in the legislation to make sure that the reservation scheme that they have, that we commend them on, and indeed, as a Western Australian consumer, I've benefited from, remains respected whilst the rest of the country tries to mimic it in some way, in a different form, of course, because it's a different market on the East Coast.
JOURNALIST: So the Coalition have indicated that there's a couple of aspects of the legislation that they can't support or they won't support. One of them is this must sell provision, and then there's another one about the structural oversupply. Are you willing to negotiate on those things, and can the scheme actually function without them?
KING: On the must sell, that is integral to the scheme. What we have seen in the gas market since the Security Mechanism in the Head of Agreement, and then more recently, in 2022, under the price cap, is we did have a system of requiring exporters to have a reasonable offer to sell, and it just hasn't turned into reasonable offers to sell. So, the must sell element of this is really important. It was also important to note it's driven investment in gas infrastructure, private investment in pipeline infrastructure to join up parts of the Northern Territory with Queensland. So that's really important, and having that private investment into those pipelines is vital for the success of the scheme into the long term.
JOURNALIST: Minister, as you said, spoke about that heavy burden that this places on industry. Does this push any possibility of a tax on gas exports even further down the road? Because you couldn't really have two burdens in such a short period.
AYRES: Well, this this reform is aimed squarely at lower prices for Australian gas users, for heavy industry, for the electricity system, and for households. That's what this delivers. A gas tax proposition means higher prices for Australians. This is a lower price reform that is about driving a structural economic reform for lower prices and future competitiveness. That is that is the choice in front of the Parliament. It is a common sense choice for Australia and Australia's national interest.
JOURNALIST: On oversupply obligations, I’m not sure that was answered before. Would you be willing to negotiate to possibly get that down? I think some of the gas companies were saying that was a more appropriate figure. Was in the order of 103-104 per cent, is that something you'd be willing to move on?
AYRES: I think in terms of the detail of the discussions, and Madeleine will come to this too, we’re engaged in good faith discussions across the Parliament. But where there are, and we're not going to go into detail about those discussions. But these elements of the legislation are really important for delivering the purpose of the reform: lower prices, and lower prices in today's economy are a pretty important economic reform. Lower prices for heavy industry, big gas users, are a pretty important reform. Parliament's got a choice. All of us, everybody in the Australian Parliament, should be voting for these reforms.
KING: Can I just add to the oversupply and then the other question? So, there is a demand calibration system within the legislation. So, if we're able to get this legislated, we then spend – not just like the regulators – the next year working on the Domestic Supply Obligations, and we can go through using the GSOO, the Gas Statement of Opportunities, how we do adjust that Domestic Supply Obligation to match that that demand opportunity. So, there is a quite a purposeful and good means of adjusting the percentage of gas, but really it is important to have that oversupply. We don't get the outcomes that we want, and legislating it lower just reduces the flexibility in all of this. And we want it to be flexible, but we also want it to work. We want it to work in the interests of Australians.
JOURNALIST: Can I just ask on the story about the Chinese iron ore exports? The words you used earlier were market manipulation or something similar. Is there anything that Australia can do there or is something that we just have to suck up and deal with these international kind of decisions by China?
KING: Well, the iron ore industry of the Pilbara has been vital to our national economy for decades and decades, and it continues to be. And there is no replacement for iron ore in terms of its the volume it exports, its contribution to GDP. I think the port of Port Hedland contributes 3 per cent of our Gross Domestic Product, so it's a really significant part of our economy. The Australian Government supports open and free trade, and when there is any kind of manipulation or changes to that, that is cause for concern. We know China has banned export of particular minerals in rare earths and so forth, because of their production power. And on this side now, as a consumer, they are looking to adjust the price downward to their advantage which would be difficult for our economy. So, we will keep working with the iron ore producers.
Diversification in trade is what's really important to add to our national resilience. I said earlier that nothing can replace iron ore, but we can have, and must make sure we have, a diversification of other products and other markets to build that national resilience. And that's why the European Union and Australian Free Trade Agreement and agreeing to that is vital, so that we can have groups of countries, the 27 in the EU and Australia, being of the same mind that we should have open trade. We should have free trade, and we should have tariff-free trade and less market manipulation. There's a lot we have to do in relation to maintaining a global position on that that open trade world, which has suffered a lot of attacks from a lot of different places that we might not have expected a mere few years ago. But that's what we'll keep working on.
You were reading: Press conference, Blue Room, Parliament from The Hon Madeleine King MP.
Ministers for the Department of Industry, Science and Resources